History of the Journal
List of Reviewers

Reviewing

Mineralogia utilises the peer-review approach. Each manuscript is reviewed by anonymous reviewers (in case of original or review papers from two to four reviewers; short-notes from one to two reviewers).

Reviewers are asked to prepare reviews according to the following points:
  • General Overview (Manuscript Rating Card)
    • The subject addressed in this article is worthy of publication (1 - not, 2 - I am not sure, 3 - yes)
    • Please, rate the degree of innovation/novelty of the research presented in the manuscript. (1 - none, 2 - low, 3 - medium, 4 - high, 5 - outstanding)
    • The conclusions were supported by the data. (1 - not, 2 - most of them not, 3 - half of them yes, 4 - most of them yes, 5 - yes)
  • Custom Review Questions
    • Is this manuscript of the quality you expect to see in a high level journal? Rate it from 1 (poor quality) to 5 (top quality)
    • Are the major innovative points of this study clearly explained in the abstract section?
    • Please, rate the degree of innovation/novelty of the research presented in the manuscript.
    • Is the study of general or local meaning? Please, rate from 1 (local) to 5 (general).
    • Does the author give sufficient credit to related work?
    • Please, rate the quality of the language and writing style.
    • Is language revision by English native speakers necessary?
    • Should the text be shortened?
    • Should the figures and/or tables be improved?
  • Reviewer Recommendation Term

List of reviewers of papers submitted in 2014

Marius Bodor
Jean Bernard Diatta
Ryszard Kryza
Juraj Majzlan
Maciej Manecki
Leszek Marynowski
Galina Pavlova
Krzysztof Szopa



List of reviewers of papers submitted in 2012-2013

Paweł Aleksandrowski
Shehata Ali

Igor Broska
Hreve Bochernes
Heike Bradl
Jan Bromowicz
Igor Broska
Kurt Bucher

Martin Chovan
Robert N. Clayton
Juan Ramon Colmenero
James G. Crock
Wei Cy
Franciszek Czechowski

Guillaume Dera
Sabina Dołęgoska
Hilary Downes

Ray L. Frost

Evgeny Galuskin
Agnieszka Galuszka
Arkadij Edurdovich Glikin
Sandra Gravie-Lok
Guilherme A.R. Gualda

Piotr Jezierki
Michael Joachimski

Leyla Kalender
Stephen E. Kaczmarek
Slawomir Kadrow
Laszlo Kocsis
Milan Kohut
Maciej Kotarba
Ryszard Kryza
Barbara Kwiecińska

Anna Ladenberger
Paul J. lamothe

Bibhuranjan Nayak

Maciej Manecki
Khakhathi L. Mandiwana
Michael Marks
Leszek Marynowski
Fancong Meng
Philip A. Meyers
Artur Michalik
Tadeusz Michałowski
Stanisław Mikulski
Zdzisław Migaszewski
Enver Murad
Andrzej Muszyński

Eric H. Oelkers
Ismet Özgenç

Manoj Pandit
Galina Pavlova
Jadwiga Pieczonka
Anna Pietranik
Galina Pavlova
Franco Pirajno
Jacek Puziewicz

John Rakovan
Krzysztof Ruebenbauer

Zbigniew Sawłowicz
Kirk G. Scheckel
Barıș Semiz
Marek Slobodnik
Roman Skala
Alasdair Skelton
Michał Skiba
Andrzej Slaczka
Miroslav Stemprok

M. Rosa Martinez-Tarazona
Anna Trave
Eva-Lena Tullborg

Pavel Uher

Johan T. Villiers

Agnieszka Węgrzyn
Janina Wiszniewska

Jiří Zachariáš
Ąndrzej Żelaźniewicz
Kai-Jun Zhang
Jerzy Żaba
Elżbieta Żądzińska


List of reviewers of papers submitted in 2011

Hervé Bocherens
Heike Bradl
Jan Bromowicz
Igor Broska

Robert N. Clayton
Juan Ramón Colmenero
James G. Crock
Wei Cy
Franciszek Czechowski

Guillaume Dera
Sabina Dołęgowska

Agnieszka Gałuszka
Sandra Garvie-Lok

Piotr Jezierski
Michael Joachimski


Sławomir Kadrow
László Kocsis
Milan Kohút
Maciej Kotarba
Ryszard Kryza
Barbara Kwiecińska

Anna Ladenberger
Paul J. Lamothe

Maciej Manecki
Khakhathi L. Mandiwana
Leszek Marynowski
Philip A. Meyers
Artur Michalik
Zdzisław Migaszewski
Andrzej Muszyński


Galina Pavlova
Franco Pirajno

Zbigniew Sawłowicz
Kirk G. Scheckel
Miroslav Štemprok
Andrzej Ślączka

M. Rosa Martínez-Tarazona
Anna Travé
Eva-Lena Tullborg

Johan de Villiers

Jerzy Żaba
Elżbieta Żądzińska


List of reviewers 2005-2010

Adnan A. M. Aqrawi
Marek Awdankiewicz

Hervé Bocherens
Krzysztof Bahranowski
Maria Boni
Olaf Borkiewicz
Gregor Borg
Ömer Bozkaya
Igor Broska
Bartosz Budzyń

Jerzy Cabała
Martin Chovan
Stefan Claesson
Nigel Cook

Harald Dill
Elżbieta Dubińska

Jerzy Fijał
Fritz Finger

Evgeny Galuskin
Irina O. Galuskina
Michał Gradziński
Piotr Gunia

Wiesław Heflik
Callum J. Hetherington
Volker Hoeck
James Hower
Vrastislav Hurai

Janusz Janeczek
Stanislav Jeleň
Łukasz Karwowski
Pádhraig S. Kennan
Urs Klötzli
Zenon Kłapyta
Anna Sophia Knox
Jürgen Koepke
Peter Komadel
Ewa Koszowska
Stanisław Kowalak
Andrzej Kozłowski
Ryszard Kryza
Henryk Kucha
Kare Kullerud
Barbara Kwiecińska

Rune B. Larsen
Jaromir Leichman
Vladimir P. Lutoev
Marek Łaniecki

Raymond Macdonald
Jarosław Majka
Andrzej Manecki
Maciej Manecki
Leszek Marynowski
Jan Michalik
Marek Michalik
Ksenia Mochnacka
Jean Marc Montel
Antoni Muszer
Andrzej Muszyński
Marek Muszyński

Svetlana N. Nenasheva
Wiesława Nocuń-Wczelik
Milan Novak
Nestor Oszczypko

Gerard Panczer
Jan Parafiniuk
Adam Pieczka
Adam Piestrzyński
Jaroslav Pršek
Wilhelm Puttmann
Jacek Puziewicz

John Rakovan
Mariusz Rospondek

Maria Sass-Gustkiewicz
Zbigniew Sawłowicz
Janusz Skoczylas
Ewa Słaby
Maja Stanisławska
Mary C. Stiner
Eligiusz Szełęg
Jan Środoń

Thomas Tütken

Pavel Uher

Max Wilke
Michael Williams

Witold Żabiński